- the source for market opinions


October 13, 2018 | Money – the idea emerges from VALUE!

Donald B. Swenson: Born January 24, 1943, Roseau, Minnesota. Graduated H.S. 1961, Moorhead High, Minnesota. Graduated College 1968, Moorhead State University, Minnesota. Designated member of Appraisal Institute (MAI), 1974. Employed with Western Life Insurance Company, 1968 – 71; Iowa Securities Company, 1971 – 73; American Appraisal Company, 1974 – 81. Part-time teacher/valuation consultant/bartender, 1979 – 2008 (taught workshops at Waukesha County Technical Institute, Wi. and Madison Area Technical College, Wi.). Retired 2008 (part time teacher/blogger), AZ. Self educated economist/philosopher/theologian:

Let’s think about the origin of this idea called ‘money’. Money, technically, does not exist within our greater material universe and there is no such ‘thing’ as money on planet earth. So why do we have ‘money’ and what is it suppose to accomplish? Money is actually ‘invented’ by people in a marketplace as they negotiate an exchange of ‘value’.  Money and Value go ‘hand in hand’ as mental concepts! Since ‘Value’ is subjective and imaginary we invent ‘money’ as a proxy (substitute) for this concept called ‘Value’.


The concept called ‘Value’ emerges because of ‘private property’. When I own a piece of land and produce a product on that land, I can then exchange my product for your product or for a ‘money’ item which you give to me. The underlying issue in our exchange is this concept called ‘Value’. What is the ‘Value’ of my product and what is the ‘Value’ of yours? We need to exchange ‘Value’ for ‘Value’ and this can be difficult at times.


We need to understand that this concept called ‘Value’ (say of my smart phone) is subjective. The ‘Value’ of my smart phone may change from one venue to the next. It may also change based on the desire of a buyer who wants to own my smart phone. Any exchange from me to you is made easier if we have invented some ‘money’ item to exchange (say dollars). I get your dollars and we monetize my smart phone with these dollars. This makes the transaction logical and real.


But what is a dollar? This currency unit needs to be ‘invented’ by some official authority so that I have confidence that this ‘dollar’ has ‘value’. In reality, a ‘dollar’ does not exist until we ‘invent’ this concept and make it real for buyers and sellers. If we ‘invent’ a dollar and then ‘define’ this name as one ounce of silver (let’s say), then I have a good idea what I am getting in exchange for my smart phone. But if we fail to define this currency concept and you merely give me the ‘name’ and ‘symbol’ ($1.00) – (from your mental thinking), then I would not exchange my smart phone for this imaginary number/symbol.


What we need to comprehend is that reality is based upon our various ‘inventions’ and we then need to convince the marketplace of these ‘inventions’. In reality, our money item (say dollars) needs to be invented and then given some physical existence. Without a definition in terms of a physical item (say silver), the word ‘dollar’ is merely a name/symbol ($1.00) which derives from your/my mind (our consciousness). It is then merely a spiritual/metaphysical concept which has no material existence in real-time.


Can you discern these issues of money? Let’s review. Money, in reality, does not exist on planet earth. There is no such ‘thing’ as money anywhere within our greater material universe. But the ‘idea’ of money is important for exchange in our marketplace. So we need to ‘invent’ some item to serve as money. Our first lesson in the history of money is this concept called ‘value’. What has ‘value’ for exchange in a marketplace? Can we ‘invent’ something which we can agree upon? If not, then barter and monetization of the exchange is difficult.


America’s history of money started with the Plymouth Rock traders back in 1620 and after. These traders (people from Europe) found that trading items with the Indians gave them items for their survival. Trading cigarettes for deer skins was one trade that worked. Trading silver coins for a bushel of corn was another trade which worked. Gradually, the Plymouth Rock leaders invented the idea of private property and the idea of a money item for trading. The best item emerged from the marketplace over time.


Over time, the best item that emerged was silver coins of a specified weight (say one ounce of pure silver). This coin could then be given a ‘name’ (say dollar) and then we could trade these dollars for other items in the marketplace. Over time this definition of dollar was changed to a paper note (convertible into one ounce silver). Then in 1934, FDR changed the definition of dollar to a mere paper Federal Reserve Note (no silver allowed). What is our dollar today? You may be surprised.


Today, our dollar is a ‘digital’ number (a digit) within our computer screen. This digit is revealed as a ‘number’ in our smart phone screen (or computer screen). This number is really nothing physical. A banker can merely ‘type’ this ‘number’ into his computer screen and then set up an account for me/you based upon this transaction. The goal of banking today is to eliminate all paper notes (called dollars) and all metal coins (called dollars) and transact exchanges with mere digits in the computer screen. Is this sound finance? Is this cashless world viable for trading internationally?


The problem with mere digits in the computer screen is that these digits are not a real ‘thing’ which we can access directly. All we can do is ‘visualize’ these digits in our computer screen. I can not access the ‘number’ (digit) as this ‘number’ lives in this imaginary space called ‘cyberspace’. So essentially our money (currency item) has evolved into a mere ‘number’ typed into cyberspace (the computer screen). The ‘number’ has no independent existence in real-time. Is this sound economics and finance?


I would suggest that a mere ‘number’ typed into cyberspace is equivalent to a counterfeit dollar unit. A banker does not need to mine or produce this dollar from the soil of planet earth, but he/she merely can ‘think’ up numbers in their mind and then ‘type’ these numbers into the computer screen. This means that our so-called money (now counterfeit or fake money) can grow to unlimited amounts (theoretically) and these ‘numbers’ (being imaginary) can vanish and disappear with a market crash.


What has evolved since our founding in 1776 is a money system which is ‘imaginary’ and without any physical foundation. Mere ‘numbers’ (digits) in cyberspace are not real objects or ‘things’ which exist in real-time. Numbers are derived from the mind of a banker and this means a banker can favor select clients and funnel these imaginary numbers (called money) to whomever he/she chooses. Is this legal and sound monetary policy? Has this type of money been vetted by our Congress and our Courts?


I would suggest that cyber digits are not real legal tender (money) and these units (imaginary numbers) can not serve as real money which represents value in exchange. What we have today is FAKE money, COUNTERFEIT money, and a form of FUNNY money. All this fake money must fail at some point down the road. We need a total RESET of our monetary/financial system after this FAKE money fails. As I write, we are experiencing a mini-crash within our stock markets. I expect this to grow in the coming days, weeks, and months.


Today, our National Debt is over $21 trillion. Our total debt exceeds $71 trillion. Our unfunded debt is some $200 trillion. And our derivative obligations exceed $600 trillion. You can witness this debt situation by going to: The problems today are monumental and systemic. We all need to understand this concept called ‘money’ and this concept called ‘value’. Also this concept called ‘debt’. Then we need to understand the difference between that which EXIST’s and that which does not EXIST.


Take the time to read this missive a couple of times. After teaching on these issues for over 50 years, I can say categorically that it takes time to learn these ideas and their meaning. Thanks for reading this missive. I am:

STAY INFORMED! Receive our Weekly Recap of thought provoking articles, podcasts, and radio delivered to your inbox for FREE! Sign up here for the Weekly Recap.

October 13th, 2018

Posted In: Kingdom Economics

Post a Comment:

Your email address will not be published.

All Comments are moderated before appearing on the site


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.