- the source for market opinions


August 20, 2018 | The Scary Middle

A best-selling Canadian author of 14 books on economic trends, real estate, the financial crisis, personal finance strategies, taxation and politics. Nationally-known speaker and lecturer on macroeconomics, the housing market and investment techniques. He is a licensed Investment Advisor with a fee-based, no-commission Toronto-based practice serving clients across Canada.

It’s a drag being a disintegrating wrinklie. And moisterdom is no picnic. But hitting 40? Terror. No longer young. On the path to being old. Expected to be adult – mired in career, house, marriage, family, mortgages, prenups, pension plans, tat removal, dental crowns, daycare, glasses, budgets, a minivan. Ayee!

You can be young, poor and still cool. You can be old, impoverished yet mercifully pitied, supported. But at forty life’s just one massive ball of expectations. Besides you may sag a little. Lose some hair. Dread a class reunion. Middle age. How the hell did that happen?

Fortunately, GreaterFool is here to help. Send in the first victim…

Hey, Garth! I followed your advice: sold my YVR condo 2 years ago, started renting, paid off all debt and stuffed the remaining $20k into RRSPs. I know that’s pretty paltry savings for a 37-year old, but clearly I had my head in the sand for a long time, and in my defence, I never had parental handouts or any education in the realm of finance. [Do I get a Participation Award, at least?]

Fast-forward to today, and I have a 1-year old baby and a husband, and I’m going back to work. Together, we net $10,500/month. Our fixed costs are daycare ($1,000/month), car expenses for two commuters, and the usual grocery and utility bills. Our savings stuck at $20k, thanks to me being off work for a year and vet bills for an old, sick French bulldog, who has now passed. European cars and dogs — fun to own, expensive to fix.

So here’s my question: given that my husband and I are pushing 40 and have basically nothing saved, how much do we need to sock away a month to ensure we’re not living in a tent city on Hastings when we retire? How much do we have to sacrifice now? $2,500/mo will get us an okay rental in an okay part of town; $3,000 will rent us the condo of our dreams. Do we raise our child on KD or buy the organic vegetables? Do we vacation at the local spray park or book that all-inclusive in Ixtapa?

Here’s my biggest fear: we scrimp and save every penny now, living just to work, but one or both of us kick the bucket before we are able to enjoy our lives. How do we come up with that magic number that allows us to have some fun now, while ensuring we have enough saved for the future? Is there a general rule of thumb? Or are we just screwed, no matter what?

Sincerely: “Late to the Investment Party”

Dear Late. Yes, you’re nicely pooched. You and your squeeze are netting almost $130,000 a year, which means the gross household income is approaching $200,000. And yet you save nothing. You have no real estate to feed. No investments. No equity in anything. Only one kid to farm out. And for this abject failure you blame the poor, deceased dog. Shameful. The Ghost of Frenchies Past will be coming to visit you at midnight.

Everything should have changed, L, when you decided to have a family. If you’re going to create another life, there’s a responsibility to look after it. Now you’ll be lucky to survive anything – job loss, sickness, marriage breakdown. To think you’re immune is arrogant and wrong. You need a plan, a budget, routine savings, an investment strategy and discipline to salt money away for the kid plus the long years ahead.

Your biggest fear is not enjoying yourself enough before one of you croaks four decades from now? That sounds like the mother of all excuses to be a hedonistic, self-centred wombat. Come back when you’re 67, unemployable, and tell us how that worked out. So, start an RESP for the kid and take advantage of the 20% government grant. Fill up your two TFSAs as soon as possible by putting aside 20% of take-home pay. That still leaves you $8,500 a month – twice the income of the average family. I know it’s a lot to ask, but cut down on the pedicures, the vacation every four months, the clothes. And what’s wrong with KD?

The goal at age 65 should be two million. You now have twenty thousand. And a bad attitude. By the way, good luck tonight.


More female forty-something angst. This time it’s his fault.

I know I’m supposed to suck up to you first but I wouldn’t be writing if I didn’t read your blog and think that you had all the answers so, I’m not really going to. Oh, except for saying I really love the pictures you put on the blog. They are hilarious.

My question is sort of two-fold… My husband is worried we won’t be able to retire early. As a result, he’s wanting to purchase some land now, somewhere where will want to retire, becasue he thinks if we wait it’ll be too expensive. (we want to stay in in Ontario)

I am 38 and he is turning 43, no kids and a dog (of course). We have a really great relationship with money and typically agree on how to save, invest, and spend it. Except on this. My thinking is that we don’t know where we’ll want to be in 10-20 years, or where his job will take him, so why waste money now on property we won’t really be using.

We have NO debt, $350,000 in rrsps, tfsa (not with any bank), and a work DC plan. We sold our home in 2013, right before the BIG boom but still did well on it. After that we moved into a van for fun for 9 months and then ended up in toronto for a amazing opportunity for my husband.

We are not house hungry, we love renting and pay $1,900 for a 1-bedroom in a really hip area of town so that we can both walk to work and everywhere else. The idea of commuting is a no-no. We both work full time, together we earn over $100,000 after taxes. My husband works in an industry that is DYING for people and he’s amazing at it so I can just imagine his opportunities continuing to flourish.

Our current MUST PAY expenses are around $4,000/month (rent, storage, phone, internet, life and home insurance, Presto/occasional car rental, and utilities). We have a $15,000 emergency fund (we both hate banks so your recommendation for an LOC was a vetoed) and save about $20,000 a year to put towards investments. Typically we push a bunch into RRSPs and then use the refund to put into our TFSAs. (note: we’ve only really started doing this once we lived in an apartment. Before, we put all our extra money into paying off our mortgage, which I realize NOW was stupid).

We’re not lavish people when it comes to material things but we do enjoy going out and pamerping ourselves (dinners, theatre, sailing, yoga, trips to the spa, etc.) and I will admit, that we could definitely save more money if we cut back on those things. Is there anything else I can share that’s helpful before you crush me with your wisdom? Feel free to use this on your blog. – Z.

Lots good here, Z. The net worth is okay, nice and liquid and fully invested. Good you’re renting in hipster city instead of owning. Overhead is reasonable, no debt, stable relationship (anyone living in a van for nine months passes the test), personal discipline – and you aren’t guilting the dog.

But get the boy to drop the hippie-lumberjack-land thing. Bad idea for so many reasons.

This may seem vaguely romantic, until you’ve actually done it (I have). For people used to dwelling in a hip urban space, who eschew cars and indulge in yoga and theatre, why do you want a life of hardship, pellet stoves, earwigs, people who wear baseball caps backwards in pickup trucks, ticks, septics and a bad Internet connection? Now imagine putting up with it all when you’re old. Yuck.

Second, it costs a pile to build, rather than buy a resale place. Raw land needs to be serviced – major money just to get electric poles in place, let alone dig the septic bed and drill a well. Construction costs are absurd (go price a 2-by-four), and the spending never stops on things you get for free with a resale (like decking, towel bars, curtains, landscaping, a garage or paving).

Third, timing. You’re right. How can you possibly know now what you’ll desire in two decades? Where you’ll be? What you can afford? FOMO has proven to be the wrong reason to buy anything – especially true when it comes to something (empty land) most people don’t want. Better idea: get him a camo jacket, a subscription to Field & Stream, hip waders and a dog whistle. He can always use it on Queen St. East.

STAY INFORMED! Receive our Weekly Recap of thought provoking articles, podcasts, and radio delivered to your inbox for FREE! Sign up here for the Weekly Recap.

August 20th, 2018

Posted In: The Greater Fool

Post a Comment:

Your email address will not be published.

All Comments are moderated before appearing on the site


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.