- the source for market opinions


October 3, 2016 | The Tax Whack

A best-selling Canadian author of 14 books on economic trends, real estate, the financial crisis, personal finance strategies, taxation and politics. Nationally-known speaker and lecturer on macroeconomics, the housing market and investment techniques. He is a licensed Investment Advisor with a fee-based, no-commission Toronto-based practice serving clients across Canada.


Sigh. It’s true. The changes announced by money minster Bill Morneau yesterday are unlikely to have much of a cooling effect on the market. More diddling around the edges. Another populist swipe at evil Chinese dudes. Some tightening up on qualifying for mortgage insurance. And a consultation process that’ll end up forcing banks to shoulder more of the risk now dumped entirely on taxpayers.

But that’s not the big news.

Buried in the announcement, the background paper, the technical paper and then deep into the CRA website are significant changes to how your Big Brother government will now be policing your family home. Under the guise of whacking foreign buyers – a tiny percentage of whom have been claiming the ‘principal residence’ exemption to avoid capital gains tax – the T2 gang have given the CRA the ability to whack you.

It’s a first in Canadian history. You’ll have to prove your home is your home. If you don’t, the money made on its appreciation will be fully taxable. Starting immediately, you must disclose to the CRA when you bought the property, and describe it. You’re required to reveal on your tax return what you sold it for. To avoid paying tax on your home’s sale proceeds, a Schedule must be filed with your taxes. If you sell the house and don’t report it, the CRA will have the right to assess a penalty of up to $8,000, plus tax you on the gain.

“Like terrorist attacks were used to compromise the privacy and independence of Canadian citizens,” says housing analyst Ross Kay, “it appears the Foreign Buyer myth will be used to compromise the privacy and independence of Canadian citizens even further.  The suggestion that homeowners selling or buying their personal residence will be a required to report it on income tax forms sounds innocent, but it’s anything but.  Twenty years from now as pressure is put on funding government pensions, having a record of net wealth tied up in the family home could place unexpected challenges upon those looking to retire.

“Anyone who believes today’s suggestion that Canadians are now required to give the government the details on selling the family home is not thinking.  The government is using the illegal actions of NON-Canadians as an excuse to monitor Canadians’ retirement finances – not something this country should stand for.”

Whether or not this is a conspiracy to trace all individual wealth, it’s still a pain. More reporting. More complexity. More compliance and enforcement. And you can be sure of more taxation.

Here are the facts:

  • Taxpayers must report the sale of the family home if you’re claiming an exemption from capital gains tax (in the past that exemption was automatic). ‘Basic information’ about the property will be required on the tax form – yet to be determined. If you don’t comply, no exemption.
  • The CRA will have authority at assess you for capital gains tax on real estate that is not reported on the tax return for the year in which it is sold.
  • Ottawa will work with provincial governments (which maintain land registry operations) to ensure that all residential real estate transactions are recorded and taxed as required.
  • The tax return, starting next April, will require details on the date a property was acquired, the proceeds of disposition and a description of the property. To qualify for a capital gains tax exemption, you must complete and file a separate Schedule. The full exemption may not be granted, depending on the details provided.
  • If you sell your home but forget to include this information on your return, the CRA will not allow the proceeds to be tax-free. In that case you must ask the CRA to amend the return. This amendment will be granted “in certain circumstances” but may also come with a penalty equal to the lesser of $8,000 or $100 per month from the sale date to the request date.
  • If you have a suite in your home, then sell it, the selling price must be split and reported. Part of it will qualify to the tax exemption and part will not. In markets with elephantine gains in home prices, this could be quite the bombshell.

Well, that’s what we know so far. Doubtless, there will be more. After all, effective today your personal residence is a fully-taxable commodity unless you take specific steps to avoid it. By taking those steps, you’re also providing the government with information never previously gathered. Given that most people have most of their net worth in their real estate, the state’s about to take a giant nuzzle into their intimate financial lives.

Will Canadians accept this? Bill Morneau and his boss think so. After all, they wrapped it in anti-Chinese emotion.

How brilliant was that?

STAY INFORMED! Receive our Weekly Recap of thought provoking articles, podcasts, and radio delivered to your inbox for FREE! Sign up here for the Weekly Recap.

October 3rd, 2016

Posted In: The Greater Fool

One Comment

  • Holly Hallston says:

    Oh my, and Trump is such a bad guy for wanting to downsize the ultimate parasite scam, i.e. government bureaucracy, while T2 is ramping it up to protect the “status quo”. Good call Garth, we should all vote for the admitted criminal Clinton and join you in the upcoming Canadian utopia. Pretty soon Canadian kids will have to prove they got their lunch money from mom and dad. Will the Canadians accept this you ask.
    They already have; remember, you just had an election in a down turning economy due to a natural cycle in commodity prices and T2, who promises everything will get better at someone else’ expense was voted in. Since the government feels it’s in the populations’ best interest to be schooled in gender studies and safe spaces for micro aggression rather than finances and cyclical business phenomena, it’s a slam dunk that pesky foreigners with excess cash and Canucks who make too much money by the government’s yardstick, but are ignorant of how to protect themselves from rapacious political hacks, will be fleeced. Meanwhile, those damned corporations and their board members will get off scott free because they read Garth’s blog and/or have a battery of accountants and lawyers on the payroll who lobby for and use the laws they help to write to beat the T2 liver flukes at their own game; for now. Yep, status quo is such a good thing.

Post a Comment:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All Comments are moderated before appearing on the site


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.