|
Obama Puts the Economic Cart before the Horse |
In his first televised speech before Congress,
President Obama asserted that prosperity will return once the government
restores the flow of credit in the economy. It may come as a surprise to
him, but an economy cannot run on consumer loans. Furthermore, credit
stopped flowing in the U.S. for a very good reason: there was no more
savings left to loan. Government efforts to simply make credit
available, without rebuilding productive capacity or increasing savings,
are doomed to destroy what's left of our economy.
The central tenets of Obamanomics appear to be
that access to credit will enable people to borrow money to buy stuff,
the spending will spur production and employment, and thus the economy
will grow. It's a neat and simple picture, but it has nothing whatsoever
to do with how an economy works. The President does not understand that
consumption is made possible by production and that credit is made
possible by savings. The size and complexity of modern economies has
obscured these simple concepts, but reducing the picture to a small
scale can help clear away the fog.
Suppose there is a very small barter-based
economy consisting of only three individuals, a butcher, a baker, and a
candlestick maker. If the candlestick maker wants bread or steak, he
makes candles and trades. The candlestick maker always wants food, but
his demand can only be satisfied if he makes candles, without which he
goes hungry. The mere fact that he desires bread and steak is
meaningless.
Enter the magic wand of credit, which many now
assume can take the place of production. Suppose the butcher has managed
to produce an excess amount of steak and has more than he needs on a
daily basis. Knowing this, the candlestick maker asks to borrow a steak
from the butcher to trade to the baker for bread. For this transaction
to take place the butcher must first have produced steaks which he did
not consume (savings). He then loans his savings to the candlestick
maker, who issues the butcher a note promising to repay his debt in
candlesticks.
In this instance, it was the butcher's
production of steak that enabled the candlestick maker to buy bread,
which also had to be produced. The fact that the candlestick maker had
access to credit did not increase demand or bolster the economy. In
fact, by using credit to buy instead of candles, the economy now has
fewer candles, and the butcher now has fewer steaks with which to buy
bread himself. What has happened is that through savings, the butcher
has loaned his purchasing power, created by his production, to the
candlestick maker, who used it to buy bread.
Similarly, the candlestick maker could have
offered “IOU candlesticks” directly to the baker. Again, the transaction
could only be successful if the baker actually baked bread that he did
not consume himself and was therefore able to loan his savings to the
candlestick maker. Since he loaned his bread to the candlestick maker,
he no longer has that bread himself to trade for steak.
The existence of credit in no way increases
aggregate consumption within this community, it merely temporarily
alters the way consumption is distributed. The only way for aggregate
consumption to increase is for the production of candlesticks, steak,
and bread to increase.
One way credit could be used to grow this
economy would be for the candlestick maker to borrow bread and steak for
sustenance while he improves the productive capacity of his
candlestick-making equipment. If successful, he could repay his loans
with interest out of his increased production, and all would benefit
from greater productivity. In this case the under-consumption of the
butcher and baker led to the accumulation of savings, which were then
loaned to the candlestick maker to finance capital investments. Had the
butcher and baker consumed all their production, no savings would have
been accumulated, and no credit would have been available to the
candlestick maker, depriving society of the increased productivity that
would have followed.
On the other hand, had the candlestick maker
merely borrowed bread and steak to sustain himself while taking a
vacation from candlestick making, society would gain nothing, and there
would be a good chance the candlestick maker would default on the loan.
In this case, the extension of consumer credit squanders savings which
are now no longer available to finance other capital investments.
What would happen if a natural disaster
destroyed all the equipment used to make candlesticks, bread and steak?
Confronted with dangerous shortages of food and lighting, Barack Obama
would offer to stimulate the economy by handing out pieces of paper
called money and guaranteeing loans to whomever wants to consume. What
good would the money do? Would these pieces of paper or loans make goods
magically appear?
The mere introduction of paper money into this
economy only increases the ability of the butcher, baker, and
candlestick maker to bid up prices (measured in money, not trade goods)
once goods are actually produced again. The only way to restore actual
prosperity is to repair the destroyed equipment and start producing
again.
The sad truth is that the productive capacity
of the American economy is now largely in tatters. Our industrial
economy has been replaced by a reliance on health care, financial
services and government spending. Introducing freer flowing credit and
more printed money into such a system will do nothing except spark
inflation. We need to get back to the basics of production. It won't be
easy, but it will work.
President Obama would have us believe that we
can all spend the day relaxing in a tub while his printing press does
all the work for us. The problem comes when you get out of the tub to go
to dinner and the only thing on your plate is an IOU for steak.
For a more in
depth analysis of our financial problems and the inherent dangers they pose
for the U.S. economy and U.S. dollar denominated investments, read my just
released book "The
Little Book of Bull Moves in Bear Markets." Click here to order
your copy now.
For a look back at
how I predicted the current crisis, read my 2007 bestseller "Crash
Proof: How to Profit from the Coming Economic Collapse."
Click here to order a copy today
More importantly,
don't wait for reality to set in. Protect your wealth and preserve your
purchasing power before it's too late. Discover the best way to buy gold at
www.goldyoucanfold.com. Download my free Special Report, "The Powerful
Case for Investing in Foreign Securities" at
www.researchreportone.com. Subscribe to my free, on-line investment
newsletter, "The Global Investor" at
http://www.europac.net/newsletter/newsletter.asp
|