Has the U.S. Dollar Bottomed?
by
Jack Crooks
"A
bottom in the dollar? Are you kidding me?" are just two of
the incredulous questions you might be asking after
reading this title. All snickering aside, I do think it's
time to start considering something as outlandish as that.
Despite still strong evidence to the contrary, there is
compelling logic to suggest that, yes, the buck has
bottomed. And if that is in fact the case, a sustained
rally in the greenback would certainly present a rather
lucrative proposition. Today, we'll delve into that very
scenario.
But
first, let's play devil's advocate and look at three
bearish reasons why the dollar could continue to slide
lower ...
Bearish Reason #1: The global hunt for yield.
Interest rates are consistently one of the most powerful
drivers in the currency market. Because currency trading
is a relative game, i.e. comparing one currency against
another, the interest rate differential is always a
consideration. As a rule: the higher the rate of interest
(real rate of interest that is, measured as the nominal
yield minus the inflation rate) the more attractive the
currency.
Of
course there's a solid reason this dynamic exists. Let's
call it The Global Hunt for Yield. Think of it as
massive pools, or waves of capital, ebbing and flowing
across the global landscape in search of the highest total
return. Often this money is referred to as hot money. And
though this is considered short-term capital, with a time
horizon in months to a couple of years, these waves can
have a significant impact on currency prices.
Currently, interest rates are a net negative for the U.S.
dollar. And the expectations of even more cuts by the
Federal Reserve in order to stave off, or at least
moderate, recession means the dollar will continue to lose
out on the hot money wave of capital.
Below is a list of real yield (nominal rate minus
inflation rate) for the seven major currencies. Notice the
U.S. is pulling up the rear with a negative real yield of
1.7%:
|
Country |
Real Yield |
3-mo Yield |
Inflation |
|
Australia |
4.8 |
7.76 |
3.0 |
|
UK |
3.5 |
6.01 |
2.5 |
|
Euro |
1.4 |
4.72 |
3.3 |
|
Switzerland |
0.5 |
2.85 |
2.4 |
|
Japan |
0.1 |
0.75 |
0.7 |
|
Canada |
0.1 |
1.85 |
1.8 |
|
U.S. |
-1.7 |
2.26 |
4.0 |
|
The
logic here is the dollar continues to fall until either
the Fed hikes rates or the other central banks begin
cutting rates.
Bearish Reason #2: There's been no panic spike
yet.
Often we see the U.S. dollar spike down when a bear market
is ending, or spike up when a bull market is ending. This
spike (often coinciding with overbought or oversold
levels) can be measured by the number of standard
deviations from the mean.
Based on research done by Credit Suisse, utilizing a
six-month time frame to derive the mean trend and
comparing the dollar against the euro to derive the degree
of overbought or oversold, here is a look at the evidence
suggesting the dollar is still not oversold enough yet.
| |
|
$ - Euro: # of std. deviations
away from 6-month MA |
|
Start of a dollar bear market |
Mar-85 |
2.3
standard overbought |
|
Start of a dollar bull market |
Aug-92 |
2.4
standard oversold |
|
Current dollar bull market |
Now |
1.5
standard oversold |
Bearish Reason #3: Not enough dollar cynics.
Okay, maybe there are more than enough dollar cynics out
there, but actions speak louder than words. In the
investment world there is often a big difference between
what someone says and what someone does. Both can play a
powerful role.
Talking can impact sentiment, which can impact or lead to
changes in trend. But typically, we see both talking and
acting bears joining forces near the end of a major dollar
bear market. That's when everyone hates the dollar and
tells you so. And everyone is short the dollar and the
open interest levels in the currency futures markets tell
you so.
No
doubt the positioning against the dollar is quite bearish
(using the currency futures open interest as a guide). But
it doesn't quite qualify as being at extreme levels for
the major trend.
Below is a chart of the euro currency future. At the
bottom of the chart I have listed the open interest
levels. As you can see in the chart, recent highs in the
euro have not coincided with an extreme in open interest.
Back in late 2004 we had an extreme open interest reading
as the euro made a new high. That preceded an 11-month
bear market in the euro (which coincided with a dollar
bull market). Using this indicator alone, it suggests
there is now more room for the euro to rise and the dollar
to fall:

Now,
for the moment you've patiently been waiting for! Let's
talk about three bullish catalysts which could spur a
rally after the dollar puts in a bottom ...
Bullish Catalyst #1: Recession.
Fed
Chairman Bernanke recently admitted the U.S. is either in
or will enter recession. So what? You're probably
surprised to see recession listed as a reason why the
dollar may have bottomed. It does seem a bit
counterintuitive, but that's the nature of currency
trading; history is on the side of the dollar during
recession. History shows, more often than not, that the
dollar actually rallies during recessions.
According to research by Adam Cole, RBC Capital Markets
Head, and recently published in FX Week magazine:
"Four
of the last five recessions have been associated with
USD appreciation. On average, the DXY dollar index has
risen 3.4% during recessionary periods compared with an
average fall of 1.2% over the whole 35-year period of
floating exchange rates."
Here
are the logical reasons for the buck to rally during
recession, as Mr. Cole cited. I have taken the liberty of
adding my own commentary after each of Mr. Cole's main
points (which I've underlined):
A.) Markets are forward looking. In short, this
means all the bad news is already anticipated, and
therefore priced in. Participants expect things to get
better in the future and act accordingly, i.e. they
believe the dollar has bottomed.
B.) During downturns, markets reward central banks
that are flexible and punish central banks that are slow
to ease policy. Well, this is interesting and flies
in the face of the argument that says the dollar can
only rally once the Fed starts hiking or the European
Central Bank starts cutting. Flexible monetary policy
and real action are rewarded. Does the latest Fed action
fit this criterion?
C.) U.S. retains some residual status as a safe haven.
Despite ugly rumors to the contrary, the U.S. capital
markets are still the deepest and most efficient in the
world. It is why, despite the dollar bear market,
America is still the place to park big pools of money in
a world full of risk.
Now,
let's talk about euro and the pound ...
Bullish Catalyst #2: Toil and trouble brewing
across the Atlantic.
As
I've said before, currency analysis is akin to being the
judge at an ugly contest. Your job as the judge is to
select the least ugly as the winner. And interestingly,
the euro and British pound are growing increasingly ugly
relative to the dollar.
The
key drivers of ugliness for both currencies is similar:
exposure to credit market problems just like the U.S.,
falling retail sales, housing markets heading into bust
stage. And for the euro in particular, some countries face
severe fiscal problems. All in all it's beginning to
hammer growth in both the U.K. and across the Eurozone.
I
believe pressure is building for both the European Central
Bank and Bank of England to start cutting rates
aggressively. (This dovetails with the point I made above
regarding the market punishing those central banks slow to
ease policy.)
If
so, the yield differential between both currencies and the
dollar would decline, and if players in the market
perceived the Fed is done and the next move in rates is
up, the sentiment for the buck could change quickly.
As
odd as it may seem, I can actually envision the U.S.
coming out of its malaise just as both the U.K. and
Eurozone become more deeply ensconced. Stranger things
have happened.
Bullish Catalyst #3: The technical picture.
The
buck appears extremely oversold on a daily and weekly
basis. Below is a chart of the U.S. dollar index on a
weekly basis. Here are the key points to consider based on
the chart:
-
The recent low would coincide with a major wave down,
indicating the next move is up (labeled as -5-).
-
And there has been a major divergence in the price
oscillators, i.e. the dollar put in a new all-time low,
yet the relative strength index failed to make a new low
(notice the divergence circled in red at the bottom of
the chart). Often times, price action like that precedes
a significant change of trend.
-
For the first time since November 2005, the dollar index
has pierced its downtrend channel, suggesting an extreme
oversold reading (see the red parallel lines on this
chart).

So where does the dollar tread from here?
As
you can see, there are strong reasons on both sides of the
argument as to whether or not the buck has bottomed. If
push comes to shove, I would say this: I believe there is
a high probability for a correction in the dollar, or
decent rally higher. And from a risk-reward standpoint, it
may make sense to play for a bounce.
Bottom Line: You and I have witnessed plenty of false
break-outs before. So even if there is a rally, we will
still need more evidence before we can conclusively say
the bottom is in on the buck!
Stay
tuned; I believe that if we haven't seen a reversal in the
dollar already, we're not very far away.
Best
wishes,
Jack |