How Unions Destroyed Greece; Union
Greed and Gall in Nevada;
Union Protests In Utah; Taxes on Food in Phoenix
The New York Times has an interesting article
Is Debt Trashing the Euro? It could easily
be subtitled
How Unions Destroyed Greece. The same
thing is happening here. Let's take a look.
DIMITRIS DAMIANIDIS is a high school teacher
and a strong supporter of Greece’s socialist
government. But that won’t deter him from
going on strike with hundreds of thousands of
other public sector workers next week to fight
for the 28,000-euro pension that he expects to
receive annually after he turns 60 next year.
“Why should I as a worker pay for the errors
in policies?” he asked, in response to reports
that the embattled Greek state will cut his
pay and, by extension, retirement benefits.
“The worker can’t be the scapegoat. So we have
to defend ourselves.”
As Mr. Damianidis and others on the state
payroll prepare to stop work on Wednesday,
fear is building that the country’s new
government may lack the nerve to cut public
wages and pension payments, which make up 51
percent of its budget.
“The risk of contagion is a real one,” said
Scott Thiel, the head of European fixed income
at the asset management firm BlackRock in
London. “Investor sentiment is now focused on
countries like Spain and Portugal, where
fundamentals are weakest.” He said that for
now, he saw little risk for Italy, given the
relative stability of its economy.
“We have a centralized monetary policy, but we
allow budgets and wages to move in different
directions,” said Paul De Grauwe, an economist
in Brussels who advises the president of the
European Commission, José Manuel Barroso.
“Without a political union, in the long run
the euro zone cannot last.”
Indeed, as core economies like those of France
and Germany show signs of economic recovery,
Greece, Portugal, Ireland and Spain are just
entering savage recessions. Spain, the largest
of the peripheral economies, announced last
week that the number of its unemployed had
reached four million — the highest in its
history — and warned that the country’s
deficit might be worse than previously
thought.
TO be sure, Mr. Damianidis is among the
smallest of actors in this saga.
Yet his sense of entitlement shows how hard it
will be for governments in Portugal, Spain and
Italy to persuade their citizens to accept
cuts demanded by Brussels as well as bond
investors.
The bonuses, he concedes with a smile, have
nothing to do with his skill as a high school
teacher. “Over the years, whenever workers
would strike, they would in some cases get a
bonus,” he said, as he sat in a local union
office here.
For decades, both conservative and socialist
governments in Greece have rewarded the
demands of public sector unions with higher
pay and more jobs.
In 2009, striking farmers were paid 400
million euros by the government — and this
year they are back again, having briefly
closed Greece’s border with Bulgaria.
Protesting dockworkers extracted big payouts
from the government in November. And the
country’s tax collectors went on strike on
Thursday even though their services are needed
more than ever.
Striking is a bit of a national sport in
Greece. Last month, the country’s unionized
prostitutes took to the streets, protesting
unlicensed competition from Russian and
Eastern European immigrants.
With concessions and accessions, the country’s
budget has become bloated. In Parliament, for
example, the administrative staff has
increased to 1,500 from 700 in the last few
years, even though the number of members of
Parliament has remained the same. Last year
alone, 29,000 public-sector workers were hired
to replace 14,000 who retired, according to
the finance ministry.
“There is no end,” said Stefanos Manos, a
former minister for the economy in the 1990s
and a persistent critic of what he considers
spending abuses in Greece. “The hiring and the
spending is uncontrollable.”
Errors In
Policy Errors In Logic
Mr. Damianidis asks “Why should I as a worker
pay for the errors in policies?”
The answer should not be too hard to find: It
was those errors in policy that gave unions
clowns what they wanted, bankrupting the
country. The unions unjustly benefited from
their strikes, so it is the unions who should
pay the price now.
Greek Farmers
Block Highway
Aris Messinis/Agence France-Presse — Getty
Images
"Calling for higher prices, Greek farmers
blocked a highway last month. The government,
running in the red, has long used cash to
appease such constituencies. "
A
raucous crowd of more than 600 teachers and
parents blasted potential state budget cuts
for K-12 education during a rally Saturday at
Chaparral High School organized by the Clark
County Education Association, the teachers'
union. While state Democratic leaders and
school and union officials all spoke, some of
the biggest applause lines were shouted from
the gymnasium bleachers.
Signs like "Will teach for food" and "A pay
cut is a tax increase" expressed anger at the
governor's recommendation to cut teachers'
salaries by 6 percent to help close a budget
gap brought on by the economic crisis.
Another sign, "Taxes not axes," uttered what
was missing from politicians' speeches: the
mention of any new taxes. The sign holder was
Joan Kissling, a science teacher at Brinley
Middle School.
Instead
of cutting the budget, Kissling said the state
needed to raise taxes "on food, whatever it
takes."
Brainwashing
Kids
Notice the greed and gall of teachers demanding
taxes on food that will fall disproportionally
on those who can least afford it, just so they
can keep their bloated pensions and undeserved
salaries.
Thousands of public employees including
teachers, police officers, firefighters and
retirees rallied at the Utah State Capitol
Saturday, urging lawmakers against a massive
restructuring of retirement benefits.
[See article to play video - Blogger cannot
handle this type -Mish]
Several bills will go before the Legislature
this session with proposed cuts to the current
pension system, 401(k) matching and changes to
the practice known as "double dipping."
A lawmaker sponsoring two of those bills says
changes are needed to prevent a catastrophe,
but those at the rally have huge concerns.
Public employees who gathered at the Capitol
Saturday are worried lawmakers are proceeding
too quickly with those changes without really
studying the issues. They feel the changes
could hurt the recruitment of quality
employees in the future.
Sen. Dan Liljenquist, R-Bountiful, has
proposed a set of bills that would cut pension
system benefits for new employees and do away
with the existing 1.5 percent 401(k) match.
If these bills pass, public employees hired
after July 1, 2011 would not be eligible for
the current pension system plan. Instead, they
could either put 8 percent of their salary
into a 401(k) type of program or put part of
it into a defined benefit pension plan with
greatly reduced benefits.
The amazing thing about the Utah protest is that
existing union members would not have to give up
anything in Liljenquist's proposal. His plan
only affects new hires after July 1, 2011.
Essentially the Utah union clowns are marching
in favor of their own demise given that
something has to give, either current salaries
and benefits, or future salaries and benefits.
Desperate to save police, fire and other city
jobs, a divided Phoenix City Council on
Tuesday approved a sales tax on grocery items
that will generate tens of millions of dollars
a year.
The 2 percent food tax will take effect April
1 and expire after five years, though Mayor
Phil Gordon said the council has the option of
reversing its decision after it hears from the
public during 15 budget hearings planned for
this month.
Phoenix shoppers who buy paper towels,
toothpaste and other non-food items at a
grocery store already pay an 8.3 percent sales
tax, 2 percent of which goes to the city. But
Phoenix has not taxed food items since the
early 1980s.
On Sept. 11, 2007, Phoenix voters were asked
to approve an 11 percent increase on the
general sales tax that, it was promised, would
result in 500 more police and firefighters. On
Tuesday, the Phoenix City Council voted to
impose a five-year, 2-cent sales tax on food
purchased from grocery stores – to save the
jobs of 500 police and firefighters. Media
reports say Phoenix officials intend to use
the food tax revenues to stop staffing cuts
announced in January for the police and fire
departments.
Taxes are a poor substitute for doing the
heavy lifting of re-thinking, reorganizing,
and re-prioritizing government. Phoenix City
Councilman Sal DiCiccio has pointed out that
the average cost for a Phoenix city employee
is $100,000. In just the past six years, the
City of Phoenix budget grew by 59.6 percent,
more than double the sum of inflation and
population growth.
The current economic downturn started early in
2007, but the fiscal 2010 budget was the first
time that Phoenix actually reduced overall
spending. Operating expenditures were cut by
just 0.6 percent. The General Fund budget,
currently only 44 percent of the total budget,
saw its first reduction in fiscal 2009.
Clearly, there is a failure by the City of
Phoenix to address fundamental reform in the
face of shrinking tax revenues.
Tax The Poor To
Benefit The Rich
In 6 years the Phoenix budget increased a
whopping 59%!
Earth To Phoenix City Council: At contract
renewal time, the unions will be asking for a
raise. Will you up the taxes to 4%, then 8%,
then 12%? When will you and your bloated
bureaucracy have the decency to tell union thugs
to go to hell?
Phoenix voters, please stand by council members
Sal DiCiccio, Bill Gates and Peggy Neely. They
deserve your support. Give the rest of the
complete fools the boot, including the mayor.
Then elect a mayor willing to declare
bankruptcy. That is your only hope.
Content provided as
general information only and should not be taken as investment
advice. All site content, including advertisements, shall not be
construed as a recommendation to buy or sell any security or
financial instrument, or to participate in any particular
trading or investment strategy. The ideas expressed on this site
are solely the opinions of the author(s) who may or may not have
a position in any company or advertiser referenced above. Any
action that you take as a result of information, analysis, or
advertisement on this site is ultimately your responsibility.
Consult your investment advisor before making any investment
decisions.